Skip Navigation
We use cookies to offer you a better browsing experience, provide ads, analyze site traffic, and personalize content. If you continue to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies.
Commentary

Hoy: Now we know who Idaho’s vouchers serve. It’s time to repeal them.

IEA President Peggy Hoy says the state’s first report on Idaho’s $50 million voucher program confirms what Idahoans feared: the money is going mostly to wealthy families who never used public schools. It’s time to repeal it.
woman in blue blazer with black background

When lawmakers created Idaho’s private school voucher program in 2025, Idahoans were promised opportunity. Vouchers were touted as a lifeline for families who couldn’t otherwise afford a different path for their kids.

Idahoans weren’t convinced. Thousands spoke against the legislation, and more than 30,000 asked the governor to veto the bill, concerned about where our tax dollars would go and who would actually benefit.

Now the numbers are in, and those concerns were well-founded.

On Nov. 13, the Idaho State Tax Commission released its first comprehensive report on the Parental Choice Tax Credit, Idaho’s $50 million-a-year tax credit voucher program.

Of the 12,216 students who received the credit, three out of four had never attended an Idaho public school. Most were already enrolled in private schools. Families claiming the credit reported an average income of $178,000, more than double what the typical Idaho household earns. Three-quarters of the funds went to families in Idaho’s three most urbanized counties. Nearly a quarter of the tuition money went to just five private schools.

This program was supposed to create new opportunities. Instead, it used your tax dollars to pay tuition for families who were already sending their children to private schools.

This is not a criticism of any family’s choices. Idaho parents have always had the right to choose private school or home school, and many do. But respecting that choice is one thing. Asking every Idaho taxpayer to subsidize it, especially for households already paying their own way, is something else.

Under the law, this year’s recipients get priority next year, so the same families will keep first claim on that $50 million unless lawmakers act.

What troubles me most is not just where this money went. It’s what we could have done with it. 

Across Idaho, dedicated educators are doing incredible things for kids every day, often without the resources they need or deserve.  

Imagine if we made fully funding our public schools a priority. We could invest in compensation that keeps great educators in our classrooms, safe and modern buildings, meaningful support for students with disabilities, and class sizes that let educators give every child the attention they deserve.

These are not extras. They are investments in Idaho’s future. Our state constitution requires the Legislature to “establish and maintain a general, uniform and thorough system of public, free common schools.” No such duty exists for private schools.

Fifty million dollars a year would make a real difference in classrooms from Bonners Ferry to Bear Lake, especially rural towns where the public school is the only school for 50 or more miles.

I’ve spent my career in Idaho public schools, and I know firsthand that in many places the school is the heart of the community.  When we invest in our public schools, we invest in the future of our towns, our workforce and our state. 

The lawmakers who brought vouchers to Idaho did so on a promise. The data shows that promise wasn’t kept. When the Legislature convenes in January, lawmakers should repeal this voucher and make funding Idaho’s public schools a priority. 

On Jan. 18, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, IEA members from across the state will gather at the Statehouse for our annual Lobby Day. They will bring their classroom experience straight to legislators with a simple message: fund the schools that serve every Idaho child. I hope you’ll add your voice too. Contact your legislators and ask them to invest in the schools that serve the vast majority of Idaho’s children. Our kids are counting on it.

Peggy Hoy is president of the Idaho Education Association, which represents thousands of public school educators across Idaho.

 

Idaho Education Association logo

We are Idaho's public school educators.

As Idaho's largest labor union, we advocate for Idaho's education professionals and work to unite our members and the state to realize the promise of a public education that prepares every student to succeed. Together, our voice is stronger.